Blog

Roof Lifespan in MN & ND: How Asphalt Shingles and Metal Really Perform Over Time

Minnesota and North Dakota experience 40-50 freeze-thaw cycles per season, enough to stress even the best roof assemblies. Those cycles force asphalt shingles to contract and expand repeatedly, loosening granules and curling tabs over time, while metal clips and seams slowly work under thermal stress.

Realistic lifespans: In this climate, architectural asphalt shingles generally last 20-30 years, with partial re-roofs or valley repairs often needed by year 20. Metal roofs can reach 40-60 years, but usually require seam tightening or repainting after 20-25 winters.

Tamko Titan XT® and Tamko StormFighter Flex® shingles both offer a 160mph wind warranty. CertainTeed Landmark® PRO shingles include a 25-year SureStart™ period, providing full material and labor coverage during the most critical early years, followed by a prorated lifetime limited warranty for long-term protection. These aren’t vague promises; they are legally binding guarantees that define exactly what’s covered and for how long, giving homeowners predictable protection and confidence in their investment.

Want to know how much life is left in your roof? Book a free inspection with Trinity Exteriors today, we’ll give you a clear, data-backed assessment so you can plan ahead confidently.

See How a New Roof Could Look on Your Home

Before the next freeze and thaw season arrives, upload a photo of your house and preview shingle or metal roof options side by side.

Open the Roof Visualizer

Storm Performance: Wind, Snow, and Hail Resistance of Asphalt vs. Metal Roofs

Minnesota and North Dakota roofs are subject to some of the harshest weather in the country. Annual snowfall averages 35 inches in western Minnesota and climbs past 70 inches in the Arrowhead, while Fargo and much of eastern North Dakota see 40-50 inches each winter. Average wind gusts regularly exceed 40 mph, and major blizzards can push gusts past 70 mph, testing fasteners, flashing, and roof deck integrity. Add to that the region’s notorious hail season, and both states rank among the nation’s most hail-prone, and it becomes clear that any roofing system installed here must endure a combination of snow load, wind uplift, and impact events year after year.

Architectural asphalt shingles rated for 130 mph wind uplift perform well when installed with six nails and proper starter courses, and their overlapping design, paired with ice-and-water shield, slows ice dam leaks and channels meltwater safely off the deck. Metal roofing excels at snow shedding and wind resistance, but may require snow guards to prevent sheets of snow from sliding onto walkways or landscaping. Hail performance is mixed: Class 4 impact-rated shingles resist puncture but can lose granules, while metal typically stays watertight yet can suffer visible denting that may not be covered under cosmetic warranty provisions.

For most homeowners, asphalt shingles offer the best combination of storm protection, repairability, and cost control. They provide a balanced defense against snow, wind, and hail while allowing fast, predictable repairs when damage does occur. Metal can deliver exceptional durability and snow performance, but often demands a higher upfront investment and added snow-management accessories to make it practical for residential settings.

Want to know which system stands up best to your neighborhood’s weather records? Trinity Exteriors can pull local storm data and recommend the roof assembly best suited to your home.

What’s the True 50-Year Cost of Asphalt vs Metal?

In Minnesota and North Dakota, the cost difference between asphalt and metal is significant right from the start. A high-quality asphalt roof typically runs $450–$600 per square (100 sq ft) installed, while standing-seam metal systems often cost $800–$1,200 per square. On a 2,000 sq ft home, that gap adds up to $8,000-$12,000 more on day one before factoring in extra components like snow guards.

Over time, maintenance stays more affordable with shingles. Architectural asphalt systems may need a $250–$400 patch after hail or storm damage in year 10-15, but Trinity Exteriors crews can usually handle those repairs the same day. Metal panels, while durable, are more expensive to address if dented – replacements can run $1,000+ per panel and require disassembling seams, ordering custom panels, and longer lead times.

Even when you factor in one full replacement after 25-30 years, the total cost of two asphalt roof systems over 50 years still comes in 30–40% lower than a single metal installation. Asphalt also benefits from faster material availability and lower labor premiums during peak storm-repair seasons.

Insurance tips the scales further. Class 4 impact-rated shingles can earn up to 30% annual premium savings with many Midwest insurers. Trinity Exteriors uses its storm restoration expertise to streamline claims, secure upgrades, and minimize homeowners’ out-of-pocket costs, making asphalt shingles the most cost-predictable choice for most properties over the long term.

Energy Efficiency in a Heating-Dominated Climate: Asphalt vs. Metal Roof Impact Shingles

Minnesota and North Dakota see 8,000-9,000 heating degree days (HDDs) each year compared to just 400-600 cooling degree days (CDDs), making winter heating costs the dominant driver of home energy use. In a climate where furnaces run for more than half the year, the way a roof assembly manages solar heat gain matters more than its ability to reflect summer sun.

Architectural asphalt shingles, especially in darker colors, naturally absorb and retain some solar warmth, slightly raising attic temperatures and reducing furnace runtimes. When paired with R-49 insulation and proper ventilation, this passive heat gain can trim winter heating energy by 2-3% over the season without creating condensation or ice-dam issues.

Metal roofs, particularly in light or “cool roof” finishes, reflect much of the available winter sunlight. While this is excellent for summer cooling, it can lead to marginally higher heating demand unless the attic is air-sealed and insulated beyond code minimums. Builders often add radiant-barrier underlayments or extra insulation beneath metal panels to compensate – an extra layer of cost and planning.

For most homes in this region, asphalt shingles deliver a better net energy profile right out of the box, helping homes stay warmer in winter without extra assembly complexity. Metal can achieve similar results, but only when installed as part of a well-engineered, highly insulated roof system.

Maintenance & Repair: How Often Asphalt and Metal Roofs Need Attention

Both asphalt shingles and metal panels benefit from a proactive maintenance schedule, but the effort and cost differ in meaningful ways. The NRCA recommends two inspections per year, typically spring and fall, plus a check after any major storm. Trinity Exteriors follows that standard and encourages homeowners to use these visits to clear debris from valleys and gutters, check flashings, and verify attic ventilation to prevent moisture buildup.

When repairs are needed, asphalt shingles are typically faster and less expensive to service. Small storm patches or individual shingle replacements usually cost $250-$400 and can often be completed the same day, keeping disruption to a minimum. By contrast, metal roofs may go longer between service calls, but when dents or seam issues appear, repairs can exceed $1,000 per panel because adjacent seams must be disassembled and custom-fabricated panels ordered, a process that can take several weeks during busy storm seasons.

For most Minnesota and North Dakota homeowners, this means asphalt shingles deliver a more predictable maintenance cycle and lower lifetime service costs. And because Trinity Exteriors stocks replacement shingles locally and coordinates warranty claims, you’re never left waiting long after a hailstorm or wind event.

Curb Appeal & Design: Choosing Colors, Profiles, and Warranties That Last

Curb appeal matters as much as durability, and Minnesota-North Dakota homeowners have a wide palette of shingle options that fit the region’s architecture.  Tamko Titan XT® shingles are a favorite for their deep-cut dimensional look and colors like Antique Slate, Autumn Brown, and Black Walnut – all of which complement Craftsman bungalows, split-level homes, and modern farmhouses common across the Twin Cities and Red River Valley. Tamko StormFighter Flex® shingles offer popular hues such as Rustic Black, Thunderstorm Grey, and Weathered Wood that pair well with both light and dark siding profiles.

Metal roofing is available in standing-seam profiles or stamped panels that mimic shakes and slate, but its color palette is narrower and fading can be more noticeable on large, flat panels over time unless premium PVDF coatings are used.

Trinity Exteriors can bring full shingle sample boards to your home, so you can see how each color looks next to your siding and trim before committing.

Does Your Roof Deck Need Reinforcement Before Installing Metal?

In Minnesota and North Dakota, roof structures are designed for ground snow loads of roughly 50 psf, which equates to a roof snow load near 35 psf on most residential gables. That means snow, not roofing material, is the dominant structural consideration. Still, material weight matters, especially for re-roof projects. Asphalt shingles weigh about 2.5-4.0 psf, compared to 1.0–1.5 psf for standing-seam metal, so a second layer of shingles can add thousands of pounds of permanent load to your framing.

For that reason, Trinity Exteriors follows a strict tear-off policy. Removing the old roof allows the crew to inspect sheathing, replace soft or rotted sections, and reset the system to code before installing a new assembly. Minnesota’s building code, based on the International Residential Code (IRC), generally limits asphalt roof overlays to two layers, but tear-off ensures that dead load stays within safe margins and prevents hidden damage from being trapped under new shingles.

Deck reinforcement may still be needed if inspections reveal undersized rafters, sagging sheathing, or heavy drift-prone roof sections. Trinity’s team checks truss spans, fastener pull-out strength, and deck thickness before installation to ensure your roof can handle the combined weight of materials and snow.

Which Roof Offers the Best Fire and Lightning Protection?

Both asphalt shingles and standing-seam metal roofs can achieve a UL 790 Class A fire rating, the highest available for flame spread and burning brand resistance. Asphalt systems rely on fire-rated underlayment and solid decking to earn this rating, while metal is inherently non-combustible and passes Class A testing with ease. For Minnesota and North Dakota homeowners concerned about wildfire embers or nearby structure fires, either material provides excellent roof-level fire protection when installed correctly.

Lightning is a common concern, especially in the open prairies, but metal roofs do not “attract” lightning. The likelihood of a strike is determined by your home’s location and height, not by the roofing material. In fact, if lightning does strike, a metal roof offers a safety advantage: it conducts the energy across its surface and into the ground without igniting, lowering the risk of roof fires compared to combustible materials. Asphalt shingles are also safe when paired with proper grounding systems but don’t offer the same built-in conductivity.

For homeowners seeking peace of mind, Trinity Exteriors ensures every roof system meets Class A fire standards and can coordinate with electricians if grounding upgrades are needed during a re-roof.

Noise & Vibration: Comparing Asphalt and Metal Roof Sound Levels

One of the most common concerns about metal roofing is noise, the idea that every raindrop will sound like a drumbeat. In reality, much of the difference comes down to installation quality. Asphalt shingles naturally dampen sound thanks to their layered composition and granular surface, which diffuse rain and hail impact noise.

Trinity Exteriors uses a multi-layer approach to make metal roofing nearly as quiet. Synthetic underlayment, sound-dampening membranes, and thicker decking when re-sheathing all work together to absorb vibration before it reaches the living space. Combined with a well-insulated attic, these upgrades bring rain and hail noise down to levels comparable to shingle roofs.

For homeowners who value a peaceful interior during storms, asphalt shingles remain the quieter “default” option, but properly specified metal systems can deliver a similarly calm experience. Trinity’s team can walk you through underlayment options during your consultation so you can choose the right balance of durability and acoustic comfort.

Warranty & Manufacturer Support: What’s Really Covered and for How Long

Manufacturer warranties are a big part of roof-buying decisions, but it’s important to understand what they actually cover. Tamko Titan XT® and Tamko StormFighter Flex® shingles both offer a 160mph wind warranty. CertainTeed Landmark® PRO shingles include a 25-year SureStart™ period, which provides full replacement coverage for material defects and labor costs up front, followed by a prorated lifetime limited warranty.

However, there are limits. Wind coverage stops at the stated rating, algae protection expires long before the shingles themselves wear out, and labor isn’t always covered unless you choose the upgraded warranty package. That’s where Trinity Exteriors adds value. We handle warranty registration with the manufacturer on your behalf, keep detailed installation documentation, and walk you through the claim process if something ever goes wrong.

All of this is backed by Trinity’s own workmanship guarantee, which protects you from installation-related issues for years beyond the industry standard. Together, this layered protection means your roof investment is secure from both material defects and installation concerns.

Environmental Impact and Material Availability: Are Asphalt Shingles or Metal the Smarter Choice?

From an environmental standpoint, metal roofing has a clear edge in recyclability — most steel panels contain 25-35% recycled content and are nearly 100% recyclable at the end of their service life. Asphalt shingles have historically been harder to recycle, but Minnesota and North Dakota are expanding programs that grind tear-offs into road base aggregate, diverting thousands of tons from landfills each year. Trinity Exteriors works with haulers who participate in these recycling efforts whenever possible, so homeowners can feel good about their roof replacement’s environmental impact.

Availability also matters, especially after a major storm. Popular shingle lines like Tamko Titan XT®, Tamko StormFighter Flex®, and CertainTeed Landmark® PRO are stocked year-round by Twin Cities and Fargo-area distributors, allowing Trinity to replace storm-damaged roofs quickly. By contrast, standing-seam metal panels are often custom-fabricated, which can mean lead times of 3-6 weeks during peak demand. For homeowners who want a balance of sustainability, fast turnaround, and cost control, asphalt shingles deliver both green benefits and supply chain reliability.

Building Codes, HOA Rules, and Permits: What You Must Meet Before Re-Roofing in MN & ND

Every roof replacement in Minnesota and North Dakota must meet the requirements of the International Residential Code (IRC) as adopted locally. This includes installing an ice barrier from the eave edge to at least 24 inches inside the warm wall line, a drip edge at eaves and rakes, and a complete roofing assembly that meets a UL Class A fire rating. These requirements are designed for snow loads near 50 psf, which are standard for the region, and ensure that roofs can withstand repeated freeze–thaw cycles and heavy drifting.

Homeowner associations add another layer of regulation. Many Twin Cities and Fargo-area HOAs limit shingle colors to neutral or earth tones, require architectural-style profiles, or restrict highly reflective metal finishes to avoid glare. Trinity Exteriors frequently prepares HOA submittal packets that include product data sheets, color samples, and warranty information, helping homeowners get approvals quickly and avoid costly project delays.

Permitting is typically straightforward; asphalt replacements often receive same-day permits, while custom metal projects may require plan review that adds a few days to the timeline. Trinity handles the paperwork, schedules inspections, and ensures every project passes final sign-off so homeowners can focus on design choices, not red tape.

Get Expert Guidance: Schedule Your Free Trinity Exteriors Roof Consultation

After comparing cost, weather performance, maintenance, and code compliance, asphalt shingles remain the most practical choice for most Minnesota and North Dakota homes. They deliver a balance of durability, energy efficiency, and storm resilience, all at a lower lifetime cost than metal, while offering fast availability and easier repairs after hail or wind damage. For homeowners who want protection before the next blizzard or summer hailstorm, asphalt systems installed by Trinity Exteriors are a proven, cost-effective solution.

Now is the best time to act. Call Trinity Exteriors at (952) 920-9520 or request your free roof inspection online. Our team will inspect your deck, walk you through shingle and warranty options, and give you a clear, itemized quote, so your home is ready for the next storm season